**ValuePad Puppy Pads - Super Absorbent Leak-Proof Dog Training Pads, 5-Layer Protection for Puppies & Small Dogs - Perfect for Crate Training, Housebreaking & Indoor Use**

They work good just a bit more expensive than the Sam's Members MarkYou get what you pay for so I didn't give a 5 star rating. These pads are thin with excess plastic around the pad, but they do hold quite a bit of urine. For a toy or small breed, these would be perfect. I have large breed puppies that grow fast so I need something a bit more absorbent. I am going through these twice as fast as other brands I've purchased. But again, for the price they do work. I'd like to see more pad and not so much plastic around the edges which is a waste.They work greatLove themSince Foster and Smith thick pads are no longer available, I've been looking for suitable replacement pads. These are the best I could find. Others are not even half as good. So far one pad is holding up after 4 days of use, and probably would last longer however I'm traveling and have to discard the used one tomorrow. I feel these are better than Foster and Smith brand.My elderly Schnauzer struggles with loose bowels, especially at night. Having a doggie door isn't feasible for us. I'm disabled with Lupus and struggle with mobility, especially after waking up. These pads have kept my pain levels down, have allowed for Abby to potty and not make a mess to where it's more work for me later. I'm on a fixed income and these have surpassed my expectations in how cost worthy this product truly is!!!! Thank you!!!!!I have 3 small dogs. One who is elderly, one who is a puppy mill rescue whom training is still a challenge after 2 years. Finally, my baby who is a puppy mill rescue with severe medical conditions . Due to one issue he has 5 liquid meals daily leading to accidents that the pads sure help with!I am a returning customer and am satisfied with your pads .thank you